Choosing the right dog food is a decision every pet parent faces with care and consideration. Among the plethora of options on the market, fish-based and grain-free formulas have gained popularity for their nutritional benefits, particularly for dogs with sensitivities. Two notable contenders in this space are Earthborn Holistic Coastal Catch and Nature’s Select Coastline Catch. These formulas offer high-protein, grain-free nutrition sourced from premium fish ingredients, making them a potential match for dogs in need of allergy-friendly, nutrient-dense diets.
In this detailed review, we explore the ingredients, nutritional profiles, customer feedback, expert insights, and considerations surrounding both products. Whether you’re a first-time dog owner or a seasoned pet parent seeking better alternatives, this article will help you determine whether Coastal Catch is the best fit for your furry friend.
Product Overviews
Earthborn Holistic Coastal Catch
Earthborn Holistic is a well-respected brand known for producing grain-free, holistic dog food recipes designed to promote optimal health. The Coastal Catch formula is one of its standout offerings, built around premium fish proteins.
Key Features:
- Main proteins: Herring meal, salmon meal, Pacific whiting meal
- Grain-free and gluten-free
- No potatoes
- Enriched with taurine, omega-3 & omega-6 fatty acids
- Supports skin, coat, and heart health
This formula is tailored for all life stages, including large breed dogs. With ocean-sourced protein and a balance of fruits, veggies, and legumes, Earthborn aims to deliver balanced, allergen-friendly nutrition.
Nature’s Select Coastline Catch
Nature’s Select Coastline Catch is part of the company’s grain-free line, designed with simplicity and digestibility in mind. Using limited ingredients and real fish protein, this recipe focuses on joint support, skin and coat care, and maintaining muscle mass.
Key Features:
- Main proteins: Menhaden fish meal, salmon
- Grain-free with no corn, wheat, or soy
- Includes glucosamine and chondroitin
- Ideal for dogs with mobility issues or grain intolerance
- Moderate fat, high protein, low ash content
Nature’s Select positions Coastline Catch as a premium offering for adult dogs that need a clean, nutrient-dense diet—especially beneficial for dogs with allergies or joint concerns.
Ingredient Analysis
When evaluating dog food, ingredient quality and sourcing are critical. Here’s a breakdown of what each Coastal Catch formula includes:
Earthborn Holistic Coastal Catch
Main Ingredients:
- Herring meal, salmon meal, Pacific whiting meal: Excellent sources of protein and omega-3 fatty acids.
- Peas and lentils: Provide complex carbohydrates and fiber.
- Canola oil: Offers omega-6 fatty acids.
- Flaxseed: High in omega-3s, fiber, and lignans.
- Vegetables and fruits: Spinach, blueberries, cranberries—provide antioxidants and phytonutrients.
- Taurine and L-carnitine: Support heart health and fat metabolism.
What’s Not Included:
- No grains
- No artificial preservatives
- No potatoes or fillers
Nature’s Select Coastline Catch
Main Ingredients:
- Menhaden fish meal and salmon: Provide protein and healthy fats.
- Garbanzo beans and sweet potatoes: Digestible carbohydrates and fiber.
- Flaxseed and sunflower oil: Good fat sources that enhance skin and coat health.
- Carrots and cranberries: Natural antioxidants for immune support.
- Glucosamine and chondroitin: Natural joint supplements.
What’s Not Included:
- No grains, gluten, soy, or dairy
- No by-products or artificial preservatives
Verdict: Both brands deliver impressive ingredient lists, but Earthborn focuses more on heart and coat health, while Nature’s Select puts a stronger emphasis on joint care and clean nutrition.
Nutritional Profiles
Understanding the nutritional breakdown helps determine if a formula meets your dog’s needs. Here’s a comparison:
Earthborn Holistic Coastal Catch
- Crude Protein: 32%
- Crude Fat: 18%
- Crude Fiber: 4%
- Moisture: 10%
- Omega-6 Fatty Acids: 3%
- Omega-3 Fatty Acids: 2%
- Taurine: 0.10%
Highlights:
- High protein content supports lean muscle development.
- Excellent balance of omega fatty acids for healthy skin and coat.
- Moderate fiber for digestive health.
Nature’s Select Coastline Catch
- Crude Protein: 36%
- Crude Fat: 18%
- Crude Fiber: 4.5%
- Moisture: 10%
- Carbohydrates: ~38%
- Ash: Low (~6%)
Highlights:
- Very high protein content for active and working dogs.
- Includes joint-supporting nutrients (glucosamine & chondroitin).
- Great for dogs with food sensitivities due to the limited ingredient formula.
Verdict: Nature’s Select edges out in protein levels and joint support, while Earthborn balances protein with a broader array of antioxidants and heart-health nutrients.
Customer Reviews and Feedback
Earthborn Holistic Coastal Catch
Positive Experiences:
- Dogs with grain allergies experience fewer skin flare-ups.
- Pet owners notice shinier coats and less shedding.
- Many report improved stool consistency and digestion.
Common Concerns:
- Some customers report formula changes affecting taste or digestibility.
- Premium pricing may not fit all budgets.
- Picky eaters may not prefer the fish-forward flavor.
Nature’s Select Coastline Catch
Positive Experiences:
- Excellent for dogs with joint issues or grain allergies.
- Owners praise the palatability, even for picky eaters.
- Noted improvements in skin condition and energy levels.
Common Concerns:
- Some isolated cases of allergic reaction (itching, paw chewing).
- Limited availability in retail stores—mainly online or through distributors.
Verdict: Both brands maintain high customer satisfaction. Earthborn is favored for overall skin and heart health, while Nature’s Select receives accolades for joint improvement and palatability.
Expert Evaluations
Earthborn Holistic
- Approved by many holistic veterinarians.
- Well-reviewed for its commitment to sustainability and animal welfare.
- Popular in dog food rankings due to high-quality fish proteins and antioxidants.
Nature’s Select
- Rated 5 stars by DogFoodAdvisor.com for its grain-free line.
- Praised for transparency in sourcing and inclusion of joint health supplements.
- Considered a great option for performance and active dogs needing high protein intake.
Verdict: Both brands have strong reputations in the veterinary and pet nutrition community, though Nature’s Select receives specific praise for senior and active dog suitability.
Considerations and Potential Concerns
Grain-Free Controversy
The FDA has investigated potential links between grain-free diets and a heart condition known as dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs. While no definitive conclusions have been drawn, some veterinarians recommend caution.
What You Can Do:
- Monitor your dog’s heart health if switching to grain-free.
- Consult your veterinarian, especially for breeds predisposed to DCM.
Allergen Sensitivities
Even grain-free foods can trigger allergies due to protein sources or additives. Watch for symptoms like:
- Itchy skin
- Ear infections
- Gastrointestinal issues
Both Earthborn and Nature’s Select use fish as the main protein, which tends to be less allergenic than beef or chicken—but every dog is different.
Conclusion
Which Coastal Catch Is Right for Your Dog?
Choose Earthborn Holistic Coastal Catch If:
- Your dog needs heart and skin support.
- You prefer a product enriched with taurine and a wide range of antioxidants.
- You’re feeding a dog of any age or size, including large breeds.
Choose Nature’s Select Coastline Catch If:
- Your dog is an adult with joint problems or grain sensitivities.
- You want a high-protein, limited ingredient food with joint supplements.
- You’re looking for a palatable fish-based formula for picky eaters.
Both products are premium-grade, nutritionally rich, and crafted with your dog’s well-being in mind. Whether your priority is heart health, joint support, or food sensitivities, Coastal Catch dog foods offer reliable, trusted solutions backed by both science and customer satisfaction.
Before switching, always consult with your vet to tailor your dog’s diet to their unique health requirements.
The post Coastal Catch Dog Food Reviews: Is It Right for Your Dog? appeared first on The Dog Foods Guide.
